A mistrial ends a trial without a verdict. It does not decide guilt, it does not decide innocence, and in most cases it does not end the prosecution. The question that actually matters the moment a judge says the word is narrower and far more consequential: can the government try the defendant again, and the answer usually turns on a single fact, namely who asked for the mistrial.
That distinction is the reason two defendants whose trials collapsed on the same afternoon for similar reasons can walk out with completely different futures. One faces a retrial in ninety days. The other cannot be tried again at all.
What a Mistrial Is, and What It Is Not
A mistrial is a judicial declaration that the proceeding has become so defective that a fair verdict is no longer possible from this jury. The trial is terminated, the jury is discharged, and the case reverts to a pretrial posture. It is a remedy of last resort. Courts strongly prefer to cure a problem with a curative instruction, a limiting instruction, striking testimony, or replacing a juror with an alternate, because a mistrial wastes everything already spent and burdens every party.
People routinely confuse it with four other outcomes that look superficially similar and have very different consequences.
| Outcome | Who decides | Can the case be retried? |
|---|---|---|
| Mistrial | Trial judge, during trial | Usually yes, subject to double jeopardy analysis |
| Acquittal or not guilty verdict | Jury, or judge on a Rule 29 motion | No. An acquittal is final and unreviewable |
| Dismissal without prejudice | Trial judge | Yes, the charge can be refiled |
| New trial granted after verdict | Trial judge, post-verdict motion | Yes, the conviction is vacated and the case is retried |
| Reversal on appeal | Appellate court | Usually yes on remand, unless the reversal was for insufficient evidence |
The last line of that table is the one lawyers watch. A reversal for insufficient evidence functions as an acquittal and bars retrial. A reversal for trial error does not.
What Actually Causes Mistrials
The textbook list is long. The real-world list is short, and one item dominates it.
The hung jury
A deadlocked jury is by far the most common cause and the one the law treats most permissively. When jurors report that they cannot reach unanimity, the judge typically does not discharge them immediately. Most courts first deliver a supplemental charge encouraging further deliberation, descended from Allen v. United States, decided in 1896 and still known in practice as the dynamite charge. A number of states have restricted or replaced it, because pressure aimed at holdout jurors raises its own fairness problems, and several use a modified charge addressed to all jurors equally instead of to the minority.
If the deadlock survives the supplemental charge and further deliberation, the judge declares a mistrial. Genuine hung juries are uncommon relative to the total number of trials, but they concentrate in exactly the cases you would expect: single-witness identifications, credibility contests with no corroboration, and charges that carry heavy penalties.
Prejudicial information reaching the jury
Evidence the jury was never supposed to hear is the second engine of mistrials. A witness blurts out that the defendant has a prior conviction. A prosecutor comments on the defendant’s decision not to testify. A codefendant’s confession naming the defendant comes in without redaction, the problem addressed in Bruton v. United States. An exhibit goes back to the deliberation room with an unadmitted page still stapled to it.
Whether that produces a mistrial depends almost entirely on whether the judge believes an instruction can unring the bell. Courts strike the testimony, instruct the jury to disregard it, and presume jurors follow instructions. A mistrial follows only when the information is so inflammatory, or so central, that the presumption becomes implausible.
Juror misconduct and outside influence
Jurors research the case online, visit the scene, discuss the trial with a spouse, or are approached by someone connected to a party. Any private communication with a juror about the matter before the jury is presumptively prejudicial under Remmer v. United States, and the standard response is a hearing to determine what happened and whether the juror can still be impartial.
Often the fix is removal rather than a mistrial. Federal courts may seat as many as six alternates, and under the federal rules a jury that drops to eleven after deliberations begin may still return a verdict if the court finds good cause to excuse the juror. The mistrial comes when the taint has spread through the panel rather than sitting in one seat.
Lawyer error, witness unavailability, and events outside anyone’s control
Improper argument, a discovery violation surfacing mid-trial, a lawyer or key witness hospitalized, a juror emergency after alternates are exhausted, a courthouse closure. These are less common but they are the reason judges guard against them: sequestering witnesses, disclosing exhibits in advance, and instructing jurors daily to avoid coverage of the case.
The Double Jeopardy Question That Decides Everything
The Fifth Amendment prohibits placing a person twice in jeopardy for the same offense. Jeopardy attaches at a specific moment: in a jury trial, when the jury is empaneled and sworn, and in a bench trial, when the first witness is sworn. Once it has attached, ending the trial without a verdict raises the question of whether a second trial is permitted. Two rules answer it.
If the defense requested the mistrial
Retrial is generally permitted. By moving for a mistrial the defendant elects to end this trial rather than accept a possibly tainted verdict, and that choice carries the cost of doing it again. There is a narrow but powerful exception recognized in Oregon v. Kennedy: if the prosecutor engaged in conduct specifically intended to provoke the defense into moving for a mistrial, retrial is barred. The bar is intent, not mere overreaching, which is why the exception is argued far more often than it succeeds.
If the judge declared it over defense objection
Retrial is barred unless there was manifest necessity, a standard traceable to United States v. Perez in 1824. A genuinely deadlocked jury is the classic case of manifest necessity, and appellate courts give trial judges substantial deference on that call because the judge saw the jury. Deference is thinnest where the necessity was avoidable or created by the government, and thickest where the judge considered alternatives on the record before acting.
That record is the practical point. The federal rules require the court to give each party an opportunity to comment on the propriety of a mistrial and to state whether it consents or objects before declaring one. A judge who canvasses alternatives aloud, and a defense lawyer who states an objection clearly, are each building the record that an appellate court will read years later.
What Happens the Day After
A mistrial is a reset, not a reprieve, and several things move quickly:
- The case is set for a status conference, often within weeks. The retrial date is typically months out, and speedy trial clocks restart under rules that vary by jurisdiction.
- Custody status is revisited. A defendant already detained usually stays detained; a defendant on release usually stays released on the same conditions.
- Plea negotiations reopen, and this is where mistrials most often actually end. Both sides now know how the evidence played, which witnesses were weak, and how the jury split. A jury that hung eleven to one for acquittal changes an offer dramatically.
- Both sides mine the first trial. Trial transcripts become impeachment material, and any inconsistency in a witness account at retrial can be read back verbatim.
- The government decides whether to retry at all. Prosecutors weigh the jury split, witness fatigue, resource cost, and whether a key witness is still available. Dismissal after a hung jury is a real outcome, particularly after a second deadlock.
One important nuance: a jury may have reached agreement on some counts and deadlocked on others. Courts can accept a partial verdict, so a defendant may be acquitted on some charges and face retrial only on the remainder.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a mistrial mean the defendant goes free?
Usually not. A mistrial produces no verdict, so the charges remain pending and the prosecution decides whether to retry. The defendant goes free only where double jeopardy bars a second trial, which happens when the judge declared the mistrial over defense objection without manifest necessity, or where the prosecution deliberately provoked the mistrial motion. More commonly the case is reset for retrial or resolved by plea.
How often do juries actually hang?
Hung juries are the leading cause of mistrials but remain uncommon relative to all trials, and most trials in the United States never happen at all because the overwhelming majority of criminal cases resolve by plea. Deadlocks cluster in cases resting on contested credibility, single-witness identification, or charges carrying severe penalties, where a single unpersuaded juror is enough to prevent unanimity.
Can the prosecution retry the case a third time?
Legally, often yes, since each mistrial for genuine deadlock generally permits another attempt. Practically, prosecutors rarely go past a second deadlock. Repeated retrials draw judicial scrutiny, drain resources, exhaust witnesses, and invite arguments that continued prosecution is oppressive. Many offices treat a second hung jury as the point at which the case is dismissed or resolved by plea to a reduced charge.
What is the difference between a mistrial and a hung jury?
A hung jury is one cause; a mistrial is the ruling. When jurors report they cannot reach the required verdict and further deliberation does not break the impasse, the judge declares a mistrial as the remedy. Mistrials also arise from prejudicial evidence, juror misconduct, improper argument, and emergencies, so every hung jury produces a mistrial but not every mistrial involves a hung jury.
Do mistrials happen in civil cases?
Yes, and for similar reasons: deadlocked jurors, improper argument, inadmissible evidence reaching the panel, or juror misconduct. The consequences are lighter, because double jeopardy protects only against repeated criminal prosecution. A civil case that mistries is simply rescheduled for a new jury, and the practical pressure a mistrial creates usually pushes the parties toward settlement rather than a second trial.
The Bottom Line
If you are following a case that has just mistried, the single question worth asking is who moved for it and whether the defense objected on the record. That fact, more than the underlying misconduct or the length of deliberations, determines whether a retrial is coming. If you are a defendant, the days after a mistrial are the highest-leverage negotiating window your case will ever have, and the offer available then is often better than anything available before trial or after a second one. Use it with counsel who has read the transcript, and if you do not have that counsel yet, start with the Find A Lawyer resources on this site.
This article is general information about trial procedure and is not legal advice; consult a licensed attorney about any specific case.







